Alex Salmond Asked Law Chief to Pardon William Wallace, MPs Told

Alex Salmond once asked Scotland’s top law officer to investigate a pardon for William Wallace, MPs heard on Wednesday 18 November 2026. The late former first minister raised the idea with Lord Frank Mulholland, who served as Lord Advocate from 2011 to 2016, during a hearing of the Scottish Affairs Committee at Westminster. Mulholland told MPs he could not say whether Salmond had been serious, describing their exchange as a humorous conversation that led to no formal action.
The Alex Salmond William Wallace pardon request surfaced while Mulholland was giving evidence to the committee’s inquiry into the dual role of the Lord Advocate, who leads Scotland’s prosecution service and also sits in the Scottish cabinet. The revelation, first reported by the BBC, has put a 700-year-old conviction back in the headlines more than two years after Salmond’s death.
Alex Salmond William Wallace Pardon — Quick Reference Summary
| Detail | What happened |
|---|---|
| Who asked | Alex Salmond, First Minister of Scotland 2007–2014 |
| Who was asked | Lord Frank Mulholland, Lord Advocate 2011–2016 |
| What was requested | An investigation into a pardon, or quashing the conviction, of William Wallace |
| When it was revealed | Wednesday 18 November 2026, to the Scottish Affairs Committee at Westminster |
| Mulholland’s answer | He was the wrong law officer — Wallace was tried and convicted in England |
| Formal action taken | None — the conversation went no further |
| Wallace’s conviction | Treason, tried at Westminster Hall; hanged, drawn and quartered in London on 23 August 1305 |
| Why it matters now | The committee is examining whether the Lord Advocate’s dual role invites political interference |
The Request Mulholland Described to MPs
Lord Mulholland told the committee that Salmond raised the matter during his time as first minister. “Alex Salmond once asked me — I don’t know if he was serious or not — but he once asked me to look into a pardon quashing the conviction of William Wallace,” he said. Mulholland, who now serves as a judge on Scotland’s highest civil court, the Court of Session, said he remembered the conversation because it was “quite a humorous conversation”.
He told MPs that no formal steps followed the exchange. The request never became a written instruction, a legal opinion or a government proposal, and Mulholland said he did not treat it as one. His account was given under questioning about political interference in the work of the Lord Advocate, and he used the story to illustrate the kind of approach a first minister might make to the law officer.
Conservative MP Douglas Lumsden asked whether the request could be seen as political interference. Mulholland replied: “I don’t think it was but it was funny at the time. And when I came back with the story, everyone was laughing.” The Times reported that Mulholland called the episode “a funny story, but a true story”.
Why Wallace Could Not Be Pardoned in Scotland
Mulholland’s answer to Salmond turned on where Wallace had been tried. Wallace was captured by English forces and tried for treason at Westminster Hall in London, before being hanged, drawn and quartered on 23 August 1305. Because the conviction was an English one, Scotland’s Lord Advocate had no power over it.
Mulholland told MPs he had replied that Salmond was speaking to the wrong Lord Advocate, because Wallace had been tried and convicted in England and any request would have to go to the Criminal Cases Review Commission. The commission is the independent body that investigates possible miscarriages of justice in England, Wales and Northern Ireland and can refer cases back to the courts.
Wallace had led Scottish forces to victory at the Battle of Stirling Bridge in September 1297 and served as Guardian of Scotland during the First War of Scottish Independence. His execution in 1305 came eight years after that victory, and his conviction for treason has stood ever since. A pardon would therefore have required action through the English justice system, not the Scottish one, which is why Mulholland said the request was directed at the wrong office.
Salmond’s Long Campaign for a Wallace Pardon
The 18 November hearing was not the first time Salmond had raised the idea in public. In 2017, while serving as an MP at Westminster, he said he expected a pardon for Wallace “at some point soon”, according to the Scottish Sun. The comment showed that the idea had stayed with him long after the private conversation with Mulholland.
Salmond, who led the Scottish National Party from 1990 to 2000 and again from 2004 to 2014, made Scottish independence the defining cause of his career. He led the Scottish government through the 2014 independence referendum, in which 55 per cent of voters rejected independence, and resigned as first minister that November. He later led the Alba Party from 2021 until his death from a heart attack in Ohrid, North Macedonia, on 12 October 2024, aged 69.
For Salmond, Wallace was more than a historical figure. The medieval knight remains the most potent symbol of Scottish resistance to English rule, and a formal pardon would have carried obvious political symbolism for a nationalist leader. That symbolism is also why the request drew attention in the committee room: a first minister asking the chief prosecutor to clear a national hero’s name, even in jest, touches directly on the boundary between politics and the law.
The Dual-Role Inquiry Behind the Hearing
The Scottish Affairs Committee launched its inquiry into the Lord Advocate’s dual role after a year of scrutiny of Scotland’s prosecution service. The post combines two functions that are kept apart in most democracies: the Lord Advocate is both the Scottish Government’s senior law officer and the head of the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service, which prosecutes crime in Scotland.
The inquiry followed the conviction of Peter Murrell, the former SNP chief executive, for embezzlement, and concerns raised earlier in 2026 about the then Lord Advocate Dorothy Bain’s contact with First Minister John Swinney over the case. Mulholland declined to comment on the Murrell case itself, but he defended the dual role and told MPs that no politician had ever demanded to see or discuss secret or sensitive information during his time in office.
The post is now held by Ruth Charteris KC, who was sworn in as Lord Advocate on 19 June 2026 after serving as Solicitor General since 2021. She succeeded Dorothy Bain, who stepped down after five years in the role. The committee’s findings could shape whether the dual role survives in its current form.
The disclosure landed in a week when Scottish institutions were already in the headlines, after threatening emails forced evacuations at 470 schools across Scotland. The committee is expected to continue taking evidence in the coming weeks, with the government watching closely: any recommendation to split the Lord Advocate’s roles would require legislation, and the government is already preparing legislation on other major reforms in the new year.
What a Pardon Would Mean 721 Years On
A pardon for Wallace would be symbolic rather than practical. There is no sentence left to serve, no estate to restore and no living person affected by the conviction. Its value would lie entirely in what it said about how the United Kingdom now views a figure who was executed as a traitor by the English crown more than seven centuries ago.
That symbolism explains why the idea keeps returning. Wallace’s story has been retold in films, monuments and school history lessons, and the Wallace Monument at Stirling draws visitors from around the world. A formal pardon would amount to a state acknowledgement that the conviction was a political act of its time, rather than a just verdict.
For now, though, no such process is under way. Mulholland’s evidence makes clear that Salmond’s request went no further than a conversation, and nobody has suggested that the current Lord Advocate or the Criminal Cases Review Commission is examining the case. The story endures because of what it reveals about Salmond himself: a politician who never stopped looking for ways to give Scotland’s history a formal seal of approval, even in a private joke with his own law officer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did Alex Salmond ask for William Wallace to be pardoned?
Yes, according to former Lord Advocate Frank Mulholland. He told MPs on 18 November 2026 that Salmond once asked him to look into a pardon or quashing of Wallace’s conviction. Mulholland said he could not tell whether Salmond was serious, and no formal action followed.
Why couldn’t the Lord Advocate grant the pardon?
Wallace was tried and convicted of treason in England, at Westminster Hall in London, in 1305. The Lord Advocate is Scotland’s law officer, so the request would have had to go through the English justice system, including the Criminal Cases Review Commission.
When was William Wallace executed?
Wallace was hanged, drawn and quartered in London on 23 August 1305, after being tried for treason at Westminster Hall. He had led Scottish forces to victory at the Battle of Stirling Bridge in September 1297.
Had Salmond raised the pardon idea before?
Yes. In 2017, while an MP at Westminster, Salmond said he expected a pardon for Wallace “at some point soon”. The private request to Mulholland dated from his time as first minister, between 2007 and 2014.
What is the Scottish Affairs Committee investigating?
The committee is examining the Lord Advocate’s dual role as both the Scottish Government’s senior law officer and the head of Scotland’s prosecution service. The inquiry followed the embezzlement conviction of former SNP chief executive Peter Murrell and concerns about contact between the then Lord Advocate and the first minister.
Claim checked: Salmond ordered a pardon for William Wallace.
No. Mulholland’s evidence was that Salmond asked him to “look into” a pardon, not that he instructed one. The conversation was described as humorous, it was not clear Salmond was serious, and nothing formal ever happened.
Claim checked: the Lord Advocate refused the pardon.
No. Mulholland did not refuse the request on its merits. He told Salmond he was the wrong law officer to ask, because Wallace had been tried and convicted in England rather than Scotland.



