Lucy Letby Doctor Barred From Treating Patients During Trial, Jury Never Told

A Guardian investigation published on Wednesday 18 November 2026 has revealed that the prosecution’s key medical expert in the Lucy Letby trial was barred from treating patients while the trial was still running — and the jury was never told. Prof Peter Hindmarsh, the paediatric hormone specialist whose insulin evidence anchored the Crown’s case, was removed from clinical practice by his hospital in March 2023 over patient-safety fears, five months before the trial ended.
Lucy Letby Doctor Barred — Quick Reference Summary
| Detail | What is confirmed |
|---|---|
| The revelation | Prof Peter Hindmarsh was barred from treating patients during the Letby trial |
| Reported by | The Guardian, Wednesday 18 November 2026 |
| Expert’s role | Prosecution’s key witness on alleged insulin poisoning of two babies |
| Barred by | University College London Hospitals trust (UCLH), March 2023 |
| Reason given | Patient-safety concerns; advice on insulin for child patients judged unsafe |
| Jury told? | No — jurors were never told |
| Defence told? | No — the defence was not told of the bar or the April 2023 tribunal ruling |
| Tribunal outcome | April 2023: registration not suspended; supervision tightened; expert-witness work allowed |
| Convictions | Letby convicted August 2023: seven murders, seven attempted murders; 15 whole-life terms |
| Current status | Convictions stand; Criminal Cases Review Commission application pending |
The insulin evidence that anchored the prosecution case
Hindmarsh, a consultant paediatric endocrinologist at UCLH since 1991 and a professor at UCL, told the jury that blood tests and the medical records of two babies at the Countess of Chester Hospital showed they had been poisoned with insulin, most likely added to intravenous fluid bags. The prosecution alleged Letby had injected the insulin, although no direct or forensic evidence showed that she — or anyone else — had done so.
Lead prosecutor Nick Johnson KC described Hindmarsh to jurors as the pre-eminent expert on insulin. The two attempted-murder charges linked to the insulin cases were the first on which the jury reached guilty verdicts, and two of only three unanimous guilty verdicts. In summing up, the judge, Mr Justice Goss, told jurors that if they were sure babies were deliberately harmed in one case, they could decide other babies were harmed too even without certainty about the precise cause.
March 2023: the hospital bar the jury never heard about
Less than three weeks after Hindmarsh gave his second and final day of evidence on 24 February 2023, UCLH told the General Medical Council (GMC) it had excluded him from treating patients altogether. A UCLH medical director, Dr Tim Hodgson, wrote that Hindmarsh had breached a supervision order and given independent medical advice about three child patients, two involving insulin and diabetes. Colleagues had submitted written concerns about him.
Hodgson wrote that the trust could not accept the level of risk Hindmarsh appeared to pose to children and young people, even under close supervision. In two cases, Hindmarsh had independently advised families that their children should stop receiving insulin at home. One child later had an episode of diabetic ketoacidosis, a critical complication caused by a severe lack of insulin; the hospital said it was not clear whether the episode coincided with the advice.
Colleagues also believed he was over-focusing on rare causes of low and high blood sugar while not addressing more common causes. Hodgson also recorded that Hindmarsh had questioned the reliability of an insulin antibodies blood test, telling a family it was an erroneous, fallible test. That point could have mattered at trial, where the prosecution presented immunoassay blood-test results as definitive proof of poisoning.
A tribunal, a supervision order and a registration that was never suspended
The GMC had opened an investigation into Hindmarsh on 25 November 2022 — the same day he first gave evidence — after Great Ormond Street Hospital reported multiple and wide-ranging concerns, including his diagnosis and treatment of patients and cases where harm was alleged. Great Ormond Street had terminated his honorary consultant contract in July 2022, four months before he first testified; the jury was not told that either. The BMJ reported in March that the GMC investigation had opened on the same day Hindmarsh first gave evidence.
In January 2023, a medical tribunal ordered that he could work only at UCLH and only under supervision, because he might otherwise pose a real risk to the public. After the March 2023 concerns, the GMC asked the tribunal to suspend his registration. His barrister argued suspension would stop him working as an expert witness and that no harm had been caused to patients.
In April 2023 the tribunal chose not to suspend him, saying it could not determine whether the supervision order had technically been breached, while noting the three cases did raise patient-safety concerns. It tightened supervision so he had to be directly supervised when treating patients, and explicitly allowed him to continue expert-witness work. The order had no practical effect: UCLH had already barred him from practising at all.
The GMC investigation never reached a final determination. In November 2024 Hindmarsh applied to remove himself from the medical register; the GMC allowed the voluntary erasure, ending the investigation without adjudication.
What the jury and the defence were — and were not — told
Hindmarsh told Cheshire police in December 2022 that he was subject to a GMC investigation, and in February 2023 the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) told Letby’s defence about the investigation. But neither the jury nor the defence was told that UCLH had barred him from clinical practice, or about the April 2023 tribunal ruling.
The CPS confirmed it did not disclose those matters because it had not been made aware of them, and said it met all its disclosure obligations. Cheshire police declined to comment further. Hindmarsh declined to answer the Guardian’s questions. When the judge summed up in July 2023, he described Hindmarsh as emeritus professor of endocrinology at UCL and a consultant paediatric endocrinologist at UCLH — apparently unaware that the hospital had excluded him from practising four months earlier. Letby was convicted in August 2023.
Why disclosure rules put the convictions under fresh scrutiny
Under criminal procedure rules, expert witnesses must tell the party instructing them anything that might reasonably be thought capable of undermining their opinion or detracting from their credibility, including disciplinary proceedings. Lawyers told the Guardian the duty is continuous — it runs through the end of proceedings and into appeals — and that Hindmarsh should have told police about the April 2023 ruling and the hospital bar.
Failures of disclosure are recognised as potential grounds for a Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) referral and for convictions to be overturned. Letby has always maintained her innocence, and her lawyer Mark McDonald has applied to the CCRC to send the case back to the Court of Appeal. McDonald described Hindmarsh’s evidence as pivotal, saying the insulin allegations were presented as scientific proof of deliberate poisoning and shaped how the jury viewed every other allegation.
Since the convictions, dozens of UK and international medical experts have challenged the prosecution’s case. A 14-member panel convened by Canadian neonatologist Dr Shoo Lee concluded unanimously that the babies died or collapsed from natural causes and poor care, with no evidence of murder or insulin poisoning. Seven experts have contributed reports to the CCRC application contesting Hindmarsh’s calculations and diagnoses and arguing the immunoassay blood tests relied on at trial can give falsely high insulin readings.
Lady Justice Thirlwall, who chaired the two-year public inquiry after the convictions, refused to consider arguments that Letby may have suffered a miscarriage of justice and produced a report in September with NHS recommendations, on the basis that Letby was guilty. The Guardian’s reporting has prompted police action before — its joint investigation with ITV News into David Walliams led the Metropolitan Police to open a criminal investigation. In another recent high-profile Crown Court case, Russell Brand was sentenced to 10 years and six months for rape and sexual assault.
What happens next at the Criminal Cases Review Commission
The CCRC is now considering McDonald’s application. The new disclosure material could form part of that assessment, but the commission has not announced a decision and no timetable has been given. The convictions stand unless and until the CCRC refers the case and the Court of Appeal quashes them. The Court of Appeal has already turned down Letby’s applications to appeal.
For now, the Guardian’s revelations add a disclosure question to a case already under sustained challenge from medical experts — and leave the institutions involved, from the CPS to the GMC, facing questions about what was known, when, and by whom.
Frequently Asked Questions
Has Lucy Letby’s conviction been overturned?
No. The convictions stand. Her lawyer has applied to the Criminal Cases Review Commission, which is considering whether to refer the case back to the Court of Appeal. Nothing has been quashed.
Who is Prof Peter Hindmarsh?
A consultant paediatric endocrinologist at University College London Hospitals trust since 1991 and a professor at UCL. He was the prosecution’s key expert witness on the alleged insulin poisoning of two babies at the Countess of Chester Hospital.
What exactly was the jury not told?
Jurors were never told that Great Ormond Street Hospital had terminated Hindmarsh’s honorary consultant contract in July 2022, that the GMC was investigating him, or that UCLH had barred him from treating patients in March 2023. The defence was told about the GMC investigation in February 2023, but not about the bar or the April 2023 tribunal ruling.
Was Hindmarsh struck off during the trial?
No. His registration as a doctor was never suspended. In April 2023 a medical practitioners tribunal chose not to suspend him, tightened his supervision and explicitly allowed him to continue expert-witness work. In November 2024 he applied for voluntary erasure from the medical register, which the GMC allowed.
What is the Criminal Cases Review Commission?
The CCRC is the independent body that investigates possible miscarriages of justice in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. It can refer a case back to the Court of Appeal if it sees a real possibility that the conviction would not be upheld.
Did the prosecution know Hindmarsh had been barred?
The CPS says it was not made aware that Hindmarsh had been barred from clinical practice or of the April 2023 tribunal ruling, and that it disclosed what it knew to the defence. Cheshire police declined to say whether Hindmarsh told them.
Myth-busting
Myth: The doctor was struck off in the middle of the trial.
Reality: His registration was never suspended. The April 2023 tribunal declined to suspend it and allowed him to keep working as an expert witness. What UCLH did in March 2023 was exclude him from clinical practice at the hospital — a different step, taken by his employer rather than the regulator.
Myth: The prosecution deliberately hid the hospital bar from the defence.
Reality: The CPS says it was never told about the bar or the tribunal ruling, so it had nothing to disclose on those points. Whether Hindmarsh told Cheshire police is not clear — the force declined to comment. The disclosure question turns on what the expert witness himself reported, not on what prosecutors knew.
Myth: The convictions have already been quashed.
Reality: They stand. The Court of Appeal has turned down Letby’s applications to appeal, and the CCRC has not yet decided on her lawyer’s application. The new revelations may form part of that assessment, but no court has overturned anything.



